I made a thing! Fuel tank load cell mounts on the thrust stand

Instrumenting the thrust stand

Being that I intend to be use this thrust stand to completely profile my rocket motors, I have been spending a lot of effort building the microcontrollers, software and data acquisition modules. In a sense, I feel like I am playing catch up for all of the work I didn't do on my first motor.

Since there are no moving parts in a pressure-fed liquid rocket motor, there are only a few places you can collect valuable data and even then you must interpolate it into something meaningful. One module in particular affords a lot of insight into the performance characteristics of the motors and that is the mass flow rates for the fuel and oxidizer.

Mounting rail for the load cell

I fashioned a bracket out of a 1 ft length of 2 inch wide 1/8 steel flat bar. I welded it to a 1.5" c-channel that is welded to the top of the frame.

Back of the mounting bracket

I wanted the load cell hanging from the mounting bracket and bolted to the top of the skate so I welded a pad onto the top of the bracket.

Next the skate is made of a 1ft piece of 4 inch 1/8" steel flatbar with 2 1/2" square tubes holding a piece of 1/4" steel flat bar that is threaded for the m4 bolts that fit my v-groove bearings.

Skate the the tank is mounted to

Once assembled the grooves in the skate bearings slide over the 2" flat bar mount to provide a sturdy linear bearing.

Linear bearing

Load cell mounts

The load cell is mounted between the two tabs seen in the picture above.

Load cell mounted

Closer picture of the load cell

I zip tied the tank on until I figure out a better way to hold the 2ft long tank against the skate.

Holding the tank that I made back in Ohio.

Now that I see the concept works, I am making another taller one that will have a universal mount to allow me to hold a variety including CO2, N2O and flight ready tanks.

An idiot swinging around a 100 AMP plasma arc!

Building the Thrust Stand

It took about a week from concept to build to get my thrust stand built. I had a hard time deciding between a horizontal and vertical thrust stand configuration. After weighing the pros and cons along with my experience using a horizontal test stand, I chose to go with a vertical setup because the ultimate aim will be to design a flyable motor. I also made sure to allow the test stand extensibility so that I could mount a rail in the future and test the entire rocket in a flight ready configuration. Another driving consideration was the testing of several experimental motor designs. My horizontal stand was troublesome anytime my rockets would not start because the chamber would fill with fuel that I would have to manually clean out between tests. The vertical position of the motor will help prevent a hard start from accumulated fuel.

The design is centered around a 1.5" x 1.5" x 1/8" thick walled square tubing backbone welded to 2" x 2" x 1/4" walled square tubing. The reasoning for such a strong base is that if I am testing a motor generating 1000 lbf then I will have to hold it down with at least that. Having the thick legs will allow me to weld on brackets that I can bury underground or mount to a concrete base.

There is a 24" x 20" shelf that will hold tanks and electronics. The verticals supporting the shelves were specifically one piece welded straight to the base so that they can act as a structural element should I need further reinforcement in the future. On the 1 ft over hang and 3 foot face there will be blast shielding to protect all of the electronics and isolate the pressure tanks in an explosion. I also plan on putting blast shielding around the pressurant tanks because they are simply 3 inch OD with 1/2" walled 6061 pipes that have caps welded on the ends. They aren't exactly hydro-testable.

I built a CAD model using FreeCad then using the FEM workbench I ran an analysis with 5000 lbs of force on the overhang. The upper surfaces of the legs are fixed and the trailing edge was fixed to act as a fulcrum. 5000 lbf was empirically determined to be the maximum amount of force before the stand started approaching plastic deformation. I only intend to test up to 500 lbf currently so there is plenty of a FoS to account for my shoddy welds (I've never stick welded before) with my homemade stick welder.

You can see my welder here

This was a great chance for me to learn how to stick welding because of the thickness of the
metal. Not having to worry about burning through allowed me to focus on the molten puddle. I first tried with 1/8" 6013 welding rods but it turns out my welder didn't have the amperage to maintain an arc so I went to 1/16" 6013 and it struck great but not much penetration so I settled on 3/32" and this seems to work just fine. What I lacked in quality of welds I made up in quantity!

A shameless presentation of unarguably my best weld on the stand

FreeCad CAD Modeling & FEM Software

This was my first time  using FreeCAD .I don't really know much software but I do have a lot of CAD modeling experience so that I at least knew how things should work. If this is your first time CAD modeling, I would recommend using a free trial of SolidWorks or ProE first because there are a lot of step-by-step tutorials at YouTube University. Once you get a feel for the flow of these softwares then you could move onto FreeCAD because there is not a lot of feed back and the tutorials online are fairly lackluster. At first I was having a really difficult time trying to understand the stress distribution in the model because of a hot spot that was created right next to a non-critical member. It was blowing my scale out of proportion.

FreeCad Default

I knew that this was useless to me unless I could figure out a way to adjust the color limits. So I poked around the source code for a few hours, I've never seriously coded in python, and came up with a macro that can probably be done more elegantly and in one line but it got the job done:

values = App.ActiveDocument.Results.StressValues
filtered_vals = []
Ulimit = 250
for v in values:
if v > Ulimit:
filtered_vals.append(Ulimit)
else:
filtered_vals.append(v)
App.ActiveDocument.Results.Mesh.ViewObject.setNodeColorByScalars(App.ActiveDocument.Results.NodeNumbers,filtered_vals)

I chose the Upper limit of 250 MPa because that is roughly where you are going to start running into plastic deformation and this is the result:

Much better

It improved my visibility into the stress distributions greatly!







I actually learned the most about the software after poking around under the hood. Overall, it is not a bad software if you already know how the software is supposed to perform and you can't beat the price. Free always fits in my budget!